1895 : No Team

1896 : 12-1-0

Coach: Coach Brown (1)

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
8	0	W	10-03-1896	Emerald AA	Pittsburgh, PA
6	0	W	10-07-1896	Pittsburgh Allegheny HS (PA)	Pittsburgh, PA
0	52	L	10-10-1896	J. F. Lalus AC	Pittsburgh, PA
10	8	W	10-14-1896	Park Institute	?
20	0	W	10-17-1896	Emerald AA	Pittsburgh, PA
12	0	W	10-21-1896	Our Boys	Pittsburgh, PA
4	0	W	10-24-1896	Arions	Pittsburgh, PA
28	0	W	10-28-1896	Keystone T.	Pittsburgh, PA
20	0	W	10-31-1896	Orange AC	Pittsburgh, PA
20	6	W	11-07-1896	Imperial R.	Pittsburgh, PA
69	0	W	11-12-1896	Pittsburgh Times	Pittsburgh, PA
33	0	W	11-14-1896	Keystone T.	Pittsburgh, PA
38	0	W	11-18-1896	Henderson AC	Pittsburgh, PA

1897 : 2-4-1

Coach: J.P. Wolfe

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
0	24	L	10-16-1897	Washington & Jefferson (PA)	Washington, PA
5	26	L	10-23-1897	Geneva (PA)	Beaver Falls, PA
0	0	T	10-30-1897	West Virginia	Pittsburgh, PA
0	36	L	11-06-1897	Washington & Jefferson (PA)	Washington, PA
14	0	W	11-09-1897	Bethany (WV)	?
38	0	W	1897	Marquette AC	?
0	12	L	1897	Cottage Club	?

1898 : 5-4-1

Coach: J. Van Cleve

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
23	5	W	1898	Geneva (PA)	?
0	0	T	1898	Pittsburgh AC (PA)	Pittsburgh, PA
17	0	W	1898	Swissvale AC (PA)	?
0	16	L	1898	Duquesne AC (PA)	Pittsburgh, PA
0	17	L	1898	Latrobe AC (PA)	?
16	0	W	1898	Steubenville Acme Club (OH)	?
0	11	L	1898	Greensburg AA (PA)	?
6	22	L	1898	Latrobe AC (PA)	?
28	5	W	1898	Homestead AC (PA)	?
11	0	W	1898	Wheeling AC (WV)	?

1899 : 2-0-2

Coach: Coach Walker

PA	PF	W/L	Date	Opponent	Location	Notes
11	0	W	1899	Wheeling AC (WV)	?
6	6	T	1899	Pittsburgh Lyceum (PA)	?
6	6	T	1899	Swissvale AC (PA)	?
1	0	W	1899	Homestead AC (PA)	?	Homestead AC Forfeits